Practice Growth

Hire a marketer, use an agency, or DIY: which route wins for your practice

Most comparisons line up monthly costs and leave you none the wiser, because the three routes buy completely different things. Here is how we think practice owners should price each one, and the conditions under which each genuinely wins.

20 October 2026 · 6 min read

Once a firm accepts that referrals alone will not fill the diary, the next decision is the awkward one: hire a marketer, use an agency, or DIY. Partners usually frame it as a budget question, which is why so many of these decisions go wrong. The salary, the retainer, and the free weekend are not comparable numbers. They buy different amounts of expertise, different speeds, and very different demands on partner time.

Our view, having watched firms try all three, is that the route matters less than the thing being bought. Buy a proven route to market first. Hire to run it once it works. Keep for yourself only the work that nobody outside the practice can do.

Below is the arithmetic we use with firms, and the specific conditions where each option is the right answer.

Hire a marketer, use an agency, or DIY

Start by being precise about what each route actually is, because the labels hide a lot.

A hire means a marketing executive or marketing manager on your payroll, reporting to a partner who in most firms has never managed a marketer. An agency means a retained external team, which could be a generalist shop that has never written a line about basis period reform, or a specialist that works only with practices. DIY means a partner, practice manager, or office administrator producing the work around a compliance calendar that does not care about your content schedule.

Those three things are not variations on one purchase. The hire buys capacity and availability. The agency buys a method that has already been tested on firms like yours. DIY buys authority, because the partner genuinely knows the answer to the question a prospect typed into Google, and nobody else in the chain does.

The comparison that settles it is not the monthly outlay. It is what each route costs you per new client actually signed, and how many months pass before the first one arrives. A cheap route that produces nothing for a year is the most expensive option on the table.

The arithmetic that settles the argument

Run each route through the same three lines, using your own figures rather than anyone's published averages. Every output here is a model, so treat it as a planning estimate, not a forecast.

  • Cash out. For a hire, that is salary plus employer National Insurance plus the minimum workplace pension contribution, plus recruitment, software, and the laptop. For an agency, the retainer plus any media spend, which is always paid on top. For DIY, the tools, which cost close to nothing.
  • Partner time. Value every hour at your charge-out rate, not at zero. Managing a new marketer who has never worked in practice is a real weekly commitment. Supplying an agency with case studies, approvals, and sign-off is smaller, but it is not nothing. DIY is entirely this line.
  • Time to first client. A hire needs a notice period, an induction, and a build. An agency with an existing method starts faster. DIY starts immediately and then stalls in January.

Add the first twelve months, divide by the number of new clients you would realistically expect, and compare the result against the lifetime fee value of a client, which is annual fee multiplied by your average retention in years. If a route cannot pay for itself inside two client lifetimes, it is the wrong route.

When doing it yourself genuinely wins

DIY gets dismissed too quickly by people selling the alternatives. It wins in two situations.

The first is a small firm with a healthy referral base that needs two or three new clients a quarter rather than ten a month. At that volume, a partner who writes clearly, answers questions on LinkedIn, and asks existing clients for introductions will outperform a thin retainer with an agency that is spreading itself across forty accounts.

The second is the expertise-bound work, whatever else you decide. Nobody outside your firm can record a five minute answer on what the latest HMRC change means for a client with two rental properties. That voice is the asset, and handing it to a copywriter who has never filed a return produces content that reads like everyone else's.

Where DIY reliably fails is the infrastructure underneath. Tracking, landing pages, ad accounts, follow-up sequences, and the discipline of reviewing numbers monthly all compound, and they are the first things to be dropped when the January deadline arrives. The pattern we see most often is three strong months followed by nine silent ones, which resets the clock entirely.

When a hire beats an agency

Hiring makes sense when you already know what the person should do on their first Monday.

If a route to market is proven, if there is a steady flow of work to produce, and if someone senior can judge whether the output is good, an in-house marketer is cheaper per unit of work than paying agency day rates for production. Firms with several offices, an events programme, or a genuine brand to maintain usually reach this point eventually.

The failure case is hiring first. A generalist marketing executive dropped into a practice with no playbook will invent one, slowly, using your money as the research budget. They will try a bit of everything, report on impressions, and leave after eighteen months with the institutional knowledge in their head. The partner supervising them cannot tell strong work from weak work, so the feedback loop never closes.

Our rule of thumb is that the first marketing hire should be a coordinator of a system that already works rather than the inventor of one. That ordering also makes the hire easier to recruit and far easier to assess, because the job has a defined shape and a number attached to it.

The hybrid most practices should actually run

The arrangement that holds up over several years in most firms we work with is split by who is irreplaceable.

Partners supply the expertise: the answers, the opinions, the client stories, and the thirty minutes a week it takes to record them. An external team owns the build and the operating rhythm, which covers the site, the tracking, the campaigns, and the monthly review. One named person owns the plan, the numbers, and the decision on where the next pound goes. Where there is no single owner, the work drifts and everyone assumes someone else is watching the enquiry numbers.

If you are testing an external partner, buy a defined scope with named deliverables and a reporting line that runs down to enquiries, consultations booked, and clients signed, rather than impressions and reach. Avoid long lock-ins on a first engagement. A sensible build has visible milestones in the first quarter, which is why we treat the first ninety days as the real trial period. Whether that partner should know accounting specifically is a separate question, and worth settling before you sign anything.

Common questions

How many new clients should a growth route win before it pays back?

Compare the twelve month cost of the route against the lifetime fee value of a client, which is the annual fee multiplied by your average retention in years. As a planning estimate, we expect a route to cover its own cost within two client lifetimes. If the model cannot get there on conservative assumptions, the route is wrong or the offer is.

Should the first marketing hire be junior or experienced?

It depends on whether a system already exists. A junior coordinator works well when the plan, the channels, and the reporting are already defined and someone senior reviews the output. If you are hiring someone to decide strategy for the practice, a junior appointment will cost you a year of experiments and leave you no better informed.

Can we run marketing ourselves during busy season?

Honestly, most firms cannot. The work that gets dropped first is the compounding work: publishing, follow-up, and monthly number reviews. If you plan to do it yourselves, protect a fixed slot in the diary for the partner contribution and arrange cover for the production side so the engine keeps running through January.

What should we ask an agency before signing anything?

Ask what they will deliver in the first ninety days, who does the work day to day, and which numbers they report on. The answer should run down to enquiries, consultations booked, and clients signed. If reporting stops at impressions and traffic, you will have no way of judging whether the money is working.

Related reading

Questions firm owners ask

How many new clients should a growth route win before it pays back?

Compare the twelve month cost of the route against the lifetime fee value of a client, which is the annual fee multiplied by your average retention in years. As a planning estimate, we expect a route to cover its own cost within two client lifetimes. If the model cannot get there on conservative assumptions, the route is wrong or the offer is.

Should the first marketing hire be junior or experienced?

It depends on whether a system already exists. A junior coordinator works well when the plan, the channels, and the reporting are already defined and someone senior reviews the output. If you are hiring someone to decide strategy for the practice, a junior appointment will cost you a year of experiments and leave you no better informed.

Can we run marketing ourselves during busy season?

Honestly, most firms cannot. The work that gets dropped first is the compounding work: publishing, follow-up, and monthly number reviews. If you plan to do it yourselves, protect a fixed slot in the diary for the partner contribution and arrange cover for the production side so the engine keeps running through January.

What should we ask an agency before signing anything?

Ask what they will deliver in the first ninety days, who does the work day to day, and which numbers they report on. The answer should run down to enquiries, consultations booked, and clients signed. If reporting stops at impressions and traffic, you will have no way of judging whether the money is working.

Shall we get your system live?

On a strategy call we look at where your firm leaks between a stranger and a signed client, agree a target in writing, and show you what the first 90 days would look like. If we are not the right fit, we say so.

  • 7 daysfrom kick-off to your system going live
  • 90 daysto hit your target, or a full refund
  • 2 to 4 hoursof your time to get started

We take a limited number of firms per niche and per area. If your slot is available, we work with only one firm like yours and no direct competitors while you are a partner.

Request a strategy call

Prefer to start smaller? Ask about the 20-day sprint, fully refunded if we miss the agreed target.